Should Hockey Keep The Fighting?
The NHL has allowed fighting pretty much since the league’s inception. Now the NHL general managers are going to take a look at whether they should keep it or change the rules about fighting.
Lets look at the positive and negatives of fighting in the NHL. One positive is that many fans enjoy watching the fights and it gets everyone riled up. In many games a goal is not scored every period so there is not a ton of action in between scores. Many hockey fans I talk to enjoy the fights and might not go to games or watch them if they were banned completely.
Another positive is that it gives hockey a unique characteristic that other sports programs don’t have. You can’t see all out fights in basketball and football without players getting suspended for long periods of time. That and they rarely occur. Hockey has always embraced fighting, and claimed to be the toughest and most rugged of the four main sports. If the NHL got rid of fighting, the NFL would then take over as the roughest sport of the four. Even if no fight occur in a game, just the sheer fact that “it could happen” keeps some people entranced waiting for it to happen.
Some negatives are that parents watching hockey and see fights might not want their children playing such a violent sport. Another reason is that it slows the game down, the NHL is trying to speed up games by cutting out time stopping or slowing rules. Another is the image, some people may not watch hockey because it encourages fights and doesn’t try to stop them. They may consider it “barbaric” or “not civilized”.
Furthermore, there is the offhand chance it could be to prevent injuries from occurring. If you punch someone in the face multiple times there is always a slight chance it could prove fatal. So far the NHL has been lucky and hasn’t had any deaths. I remember when Bertuzzi clipped a guy from behind and nearly killed/paralyzed him. It wasn’t a fight, it was a cheap shot, but because of the “let loose” realm of hockey, players think along the lines of “how can I really hurt my opponent”.
I think however, that despite all the negatives, the sport of hockey would lose a lot of fans if they cut out fighting. It is a much a part of hockey as peanuts are at a baseball game. Just look at how much popularity UFC has been gaining, Americans want more violence, not less. You cut out fights and hockey becomes as entertaining to an American as a soccer game.
















